|
2. Aspects of the Civil WarThe Civil War is a war of ideas, it is a war about democracy. Both sides have claimed to be more democratic than the other, both sides have claimed the other to be the traitor of independence. Thus the Civil War is also a war of speeches and of propaganda. The Civil War is also one of the turning points of military history. It is perhaps the first modern war, it is a war in which the railroad and entrenchments rose to strategical and tactical importance, thus already providing a glimpse on the horrors two later world wars were to bring to the soldiers. The Civil War is a war of contrasts - contrasting old style warfare with a newer, more pragmatic agenda, a contrast which best manifested into the two central figures of Lee and Grant. It is a war of pragmatic rationale against sentimentality, a war of abstract political agendas against a more emotional patriotism; at least in a stereotypical theoretical view. The Civil War is a war of economy and infrastructure, it is a war showing very clearly the state in which both contestants were at the time of conflict. It is a war which is closely linked to territorial and climatical conditions, but also to the technology to overcome any such hindrances. The Civil War is a war without a winner and without a loser. Like in every Civil War, the enemy is relatives, friends; family. Thus it is a very painful war, a very complicated and complex war which has created wounds which are deeper than the time period between 1861 and 1865. The Civil War is no thing of the past. Confederate flags being still an issue in contemporary US politics, Southern dialect and lifestyle being the focus of movies and television[1], not necessarily under a derogative agenda, the war and its discourse still remain present in the American people. |
3. About this PaperOther than my other study papers, this one is envisaged as an internet paper, meaning that it is conceptualized as a web site rather than a dry research paper. Thus it will focus more on personal opinion and interpretation than on consequent analysis of sources and literature. I still hope to remain on a solid factual basis, but you will also encounter some extrapolation and speculative thought. Furthermore, the nature of this paper is a more open one. While it may be conceptualized as a closed entity in its main thread, you may also have noticed that I've expanded this sub-section into other areas as well, including everything on this site which is related to the topics of the Civil War and US Slavery. Unlike my other papers, this one is open to future additions or even modifications. The main thread of this paper is connected with the thesis established in its title: That the cause of the Southern Confederacy has been a "Lost Cause" indeed, and that not only the odds were against it, but also its own management and perspective. This is connected with the second thread, listing various aspects of the Civil War, issues related to the conflict, some of them directly contributing to Southern Defeat, others only indirectly or insignificantly. The third thread comes with the subtitle: "The Civil War in Retrospect". Of course this has been written in retrospect, as the author of this text has in no way been historically involved in the Civil War. But there's also something else to it. The Civil War being an issue of the past, the analysis of this conflict is not only made in hindsight, but several issues of the War are still present in today's culture. Nothing and nobody vanishes without a trace, and an event as disrupting as a war will last in the memory of the people and in their cultural artifacts, and much more so such a dividing issue as a Civil War. The ruptures having caused this war, as well as the ones being caused by it, are still present today in one way or another. Thus this paper is not only about the Civil War, but in part also about this very act of retrospection. The Civil War is no past phenomenon. It is still living history. While it has ceased to be a military confrontation, some of its issues are living on today also. From the mere history of acts and dates, the Civil War has entered cutural history - has entered culture. In culture, however, past, present and future are merging and continue to shape history.
|
Endnotes - Introduction[1] as in movies like 'O Brother, Where Art Thou' (2000), 'The General's Daughter' (1999), 'Man on the Moon' (1999), 'Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil' (1997), or - regarding television - the Civil War plot of Babylon 5, the Dharma and Greg episode 2.14 'Dharma and Greg on a Hot Tin Roof' (1999) and the rather unnerving and infamous X-Files - episode 4x03 'Home'
|
|
|
| ||||||||||||
|
|
|